401(k) vs. IRA: How to Decide Where Your Next Retirement Dollar Goes

By K.T. Shiri · Financial Survival · Part 11 of 15

A woman reviews retirement planning papers and a calculator at a table.

A worker has US$150 a month to put aside and a new employer offering to match retirement contributions. A broker also offers to open an individual retirement account. The useful question is where the next US$150 would do more work. The answer starts with the employer’s written match formula, then moves to taxes, fees and how much of the money the worker can afford to put beyond easy reach.

A 401(k) and an IRA are U.S. retirement accounts. They can each hold investments, but the rules for getting money in, choosing what to buy and taking it out differ. Many eligible workers can use both. A sensible choice for the next contribution can also change after a job move or a year with a different income.

Find out what your employer will contribute

A 401(k) is offered through an employer. Employees generally put money in through payroll and choose investments from the plan’s menu. The plan may include matching or other employer contributions. An IRA is opened by the individual with a provider, and the available investments depend on that provider. In general, an IRA contribution requires taxable compensation, with separate rules for qualifying spouses filing jointly. The IRS guide to IRA contributions sets out who can contribute.

Ask payroll or the plan administrator for the match formula and the parts of the plan document that tell you when the match is paid. Some plans work per pay period. If you contribute heavily early in the year, then stop, ask whether the employer makes an end-of-year adjustment or matches only on pay periods where you contribute. Also ask whether there is a waiting period and whether bonuses count in eligible pay. Use the written formula when you run the numbers.

Constructed example. You earn US$48,000 in eligible annual pay. The plan matches 50 cents for each dollar you defer up to 6% of pay. Spreading a 6% contribution across the year would put in US$2,880 of your own pay, or US$240 per month. Under those assumptions the employer adds US$1,440. With only US$150 per month to spare, you contribute US$1,800 and the assumed match is US$900. Check what you would keep if you leave. The IRS explains that workers own their own salary deferrals, while some employer contributions can be subject to a vesting schedule. IRS guidance on vesting.

Compare the match with the bills still due this month. A contribution that leaves you repeatedly borrowing for transport or groceries may turn a workplace benefit into a cash-flow problem. Calculate your essentials and leave room for interruptions before raising payroll deductions. Use the emergency-fund guide to estimate how much needs to stay available outside a retirement account.

Compare the 2026 limits and eligibility rules

For 2026, the standard employee elective deferral limit for 401(k) plans is US$24,500. That is a limit on employee deferrals, distinct from the overall plan limit that can include employer contributions. Pre-tax and designated Roth employee deferrals generally share that deferral limit. The standard combined limit for traditional and Roth IRA contributions is US$7,500, or eligible compensation if lower. The IRA catch-up amount for someone aged 50 or older is US$1,100 in 2026, which brings the combined limit to US$8,600 when the compensation requirement is met. Workplace catch-up rules have their own limits and age provisions. IRS 2026 retirement contribution limits and IRA contribution limits.

Three different questions sit behind those numbers. Can I contribute to the account? Will I get a deduction for making the contribution? How will withdrawals be treated? A traditional IRA contribution can be allowed even if part or all of it is nondeductible. A workplace retirement plan and income can affect the deduction. Roth IRA contributions have their own income eligibility test. For a single filer, the 2026 direct Roth IRA contribution phaseout generally runs from US$153,000 to US$168,000 of modified adjusted gross income. Married couples filing jointly generally use US$242,000 to US$252,000. Check the rules for your filing status and any other relevant circumstances before contributing. IRS Publication 590-A.

Compare taxes using the same take-home cost

Traditional pre-tax 401(k) deferrals generally reduce federal income taxable pay when made, and taxable distributions are generally included in income when withdrawn. Designated Roth contributions come from after-tax pay, and qualified distributions are generally free of federal income tax. Roth IRA contributions are also after-tax. Each account has its own withdrawal and qualification rules. Review them before using retirement savings for anything other than retirement. IRS guidance on designated Roth accounts and traditional and Roth IRA overview.

Constructed comparison. Assume a 20% marginal income tax rate now and US$80 of take-home pay available. Ignoring other taxes, limits and fees, you could put US$100 into a pre-tax account at a take-home cost of US$80, or US$80 into a Roth account. If either contribution doubles and the applicable income tax rate at withdrawal is 20%, the pre-tax balance of US$200 leaves US$160 after tax. The Roth reaches US$160 if the distribution qualifies. At a 25% withdrawal tax rate, the same pre-tax balance would leave US$150. At 15%, it would leave US$170. This example holds investment performance and all other conditions constant and uses invented tax rates.

The comparison changes when contribution limits bind, a match is available, the menu costs more, or the two accounts hold different investments. Future tax rates and income are uncertain. If you expect to change countries, ask how each jurisdiction would treat the account and the distributions before relying on the assumed U.S. tax treatment.

Compare the investments, the fees and access

Collect your workplace plan’s fee disclosure and the prospectus or fee sheet for a comparable IRA investment. Separate account administration, the expense ratio of the investment itself and any fees for advice or transactions. A plan with a modest menu may still offer a broad, inexpensive fund. An IRA with a long menu may include low-cost options and expensive ones. Compare investments with similar exposure. A very low fee on a single sector does little to tell you whether it fits the role of a broadly invested retirement holding. The SEC’s investor guide to asset allocation explains why the mix of investments matters.

South African readers can apply the same decision sequence to local arrangements while using their own rules. Compare workplace pension or provident fund contributions and terms with any retirement annuity you are eligible to use. SARS’s 2026 budget FAQ describes a 27.5% deduction limit based on the greater of remuneration or taxable income, with a R430,000 annual cap for 2026/27 and other applicable details. The American account names, limits and Roth tax treatment belong to the U.S. comparison. SARS, Budget 2026 FAQs.

Write a short allocation order you can revisit. Start with the amount you can set aside each payday. Calculate how much employer money your contributions would unlock and how much you would keep if you left. For savings beyond that point, compare eligible accounts on fees, investment choices and tax treatment. Put a reminder on your calendar for a change in pay or plan rules. If the investments themselves are the unfamiliar part, start with the first-time investor’s guide.

Author book recommendation. I wrote The Market Woman’s MBA, about how African women traders weigh decisions involving capital, credit and risk. For more about allocating scarce cash when several needs compete, find my book in the K.T. Shiri collection.

Sources

Comments